Media that empowers working people – that's how we build a More Perfect Union.

Don't Miss a Video!

Access our exclusive reporting and rapid response actions directly in your inbox, so you don’t miss a beat in the fight for working people nationwide.

Be a part of a community backing up independent journalism with action.

Ideas

Have a story to tell or idea to share?
Email [email protected]
© 2021 More Perfect Union Action

Together we can build power for working people.

We’re asking questions that really matter, and telling the stories of people who really need to be seen and heard.

You can support our work by donating today.

Amount

Make It Monthly

Don't Miss a Video!

Access our exclusive reporting and rapid response actions directly in your inbox, so you don’t miss a beat in the fight for working people nationwide.

Be a part of a community backing up independent journalism with action.

This Powerful Democrat Is Gutting Biden’s Paid Family Leave Program

House Democrat Richard Neal wrecked President Biden's proposal for paid family leave, turning it into a complex and inefficient giveaway to the insurance industry.

YouTube Thumbnail

by Matt Bruenig, Founder of People’s Policy Project

The United States is the only country in the developed world that lacks a national parental leave program, and one powerful Democrat in Congress — doing the bidding of the insurance industry — is trying to keep it that way.

During the presidential election, Joe Biden promised that he would finally fix America’s paid leave crisis by providing parents cash benefits through the Social Security Administration to cover a portion of their wages for 12 weeks after the birth or adoption of a child. Twelve weeks of paid leave is a modest amount compared to our peer countries, but it would be a decent start for a country that currently offers parents no help at all.

But, in the last few months, the Biden plan has hit an obstacle in the House of Representatives. Congressman Richard Neal, the chair of the powerful Ways & Means Committee, has replaced the Biden paid leave plan with a much worse proposal endorsed by the private insurance industry.

Under the Neal proposal, parental leave would no longer be provided publicly through the Social Security program. Instead, the federal government would give cash to businesses so that they could pay private insurance companies to provide paid leave benefits for their workers.

The Neal plan has won the praise of the Life Insurance Lobby and support from one of the nation’s largest insurance companies, Sun Life. But it would be a disaster for new parents who would be forced to navigate a much more complicated system run by insurance companies that make money by denying benefit claims and adding wasteful administrative costs. It would also be a disaster for the federal budget because businesses with workforces that take a below-average amount of paid leave would be able to extract money out of the system for their own profit.

In addition to needlessly turning Biden’s paid leave ambitions into a private insurance giveaway, the Neal benefit proposal has three major design problems that would severely reduce the effectiveness of the program.

The first problem is that new parents who do not work in the 3 to 6 months prior to giving birth would be ineligible to receive any benefits from the program. This means that parents who are still in education, parents with work-limiting disabilities, and parents facing an unluckily-timed spell of unemployment would be excluded from the program. Altogether this design would keep around 1 in 3 new mothers from claiming benefits.

The second problem is that the program has no minimum benefit level. Instead, workers only receive a benefit equal to, at most, 85 percent of the wages they were earning prior to having a child. Low-wage workers who cannot afford to give up 15 percent of their pay would not be able to access the program even though they are technically eligible for it.

The third problem is that the program provides 12 weeks of leave per parent with no option to transfer any of those weeks between parents. This means that two-parent families are eligible for twice as much leave as one-parent families, which also means higher child care bills for one-parent families.

Passing a poorly designed paid leave proposal is a dangerous political game for Democrats. Voters would rightly blame them for the difficult and inefficient program that they’ve now been forced to deal with, wiping away what should have been a political winner. When we make voters feel government can’t deliver, it hurts the entirety of the progressive agenda.

It would be very easy to create a paid leave system without these problems. Congress could pass a bill that establishes a public paid leave program through the Social Security Administration that pays all new parents at least the minimum wage during their parental leave period and that gives families a total of 24 weeks that they could split between parents in whatever way they prefer. But Congress needs to act quickly. If it doesn’t, Biden’s Build Back Better Agenda will fall prey to the Insurance Company Agenda.

Matt Bruenig is the founder of the People’s Policy Project.

The Latest

YouTube Thumbnail
Republicans Want You to Work Until You Die
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Elon Musk’s Firing Spree Continues: Twitter Janitors Terminated Via Text
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Four Lies Big Oil Is Feeding You To Keep Gas Prices High
Read More
Wall Street Banks Huge Profits Off Surging Credit Card Debt
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
How Workers Took On A Manufacturing Giant—and Won
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Playing with Players’ Lives: How the NFL Hid a Crisis Killing Athletes
Read More
Kyrsten Sinema
Sinema’s Private Equity Donations Keep Flowing After Saving Tax Loophole
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Moderna To Raise Prices Over 400% For Vaccine That Taxpayers Helped Create
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
How The Supreme Court Could Soon Destroy The Right To Strike
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Cities Are Canceling Medical Debt Thanks to Democrats’ American Rescue Plan
Read More
Bed, Bath & Beyond
Bed, Bath & Beyond’s Ex-CEO Got Rich Bankrupting the Retailer, Now Workers Stand to Lose
Read More
Rep. Virginia Foxx
Millionaire Stock Trader To Lead House Labor Committee For GOP
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
The Fight For $20 Comes To New York
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Inside A Trader Joe’s Union Contract Bargaining Session
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
How This Billionaire Couple Stole California’s Water Supply
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
La Colombe Coffee Workers Are Unionizing
Read More
Kevin McCarthy Vowed To Take On Congressional Stock Trading. Now He’s Gone Silent.
Read More
Schumer Freezes Antitrust Bills After Big Tech Lobbyists Bundled Millions
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
How Joe Biden Could Stop Shady Union-Busting Practices
Read More
Rail Workers Oust Union President Who Backed Labor Deal
Read More