Media that empowers working people – that's how we build a More Perfect Union.

Don't Miss a Video!

Access our exclusive reporting and rapid response actions directly in your inbox, so you don’t miss a beat in the fight for working people nationwide.

Be a part of a community backing up independent journalism with action.

Ideas

Have a story to tell or idea to share?
Email [email protected]
© 2021 More Perfect Union Action

Together we can build power for working people.

We’re asking questions that really matter, and telling the stories of people who really need to be seen and heard.

You can support our work by donating today.

Amount

Make It Monthly

Don't Miss a Video!

Access our exclusive reporting and rapid response actions directly in your inbox, so you don’t miss a beat in the fight for working people nationwide.

Be a part of a community backing up independent journalism with action.

Republicans Wage War to Deny More Than 800,000 Disabled and Elderly Americans Home Care

Brandon Ingram was a model employee at Frito-Lay. But that meant nothing to the company after he was electrocuted operating routine equipment: they refused to properly compensate him and surveilled his family for years to undermine his disability claim.

YouTube Thumbnail

When Lila Carpenter turned four, she was diagnosed with autism and other intellectual disabilities. Her doctors emphasized the importance of early intervention; her father Geoff Carpenter recalled that at that time “there was no real wait and see kind of alternative.” But Medicaid only guarantees coverage for care in nursing homes and institutions, not the local physical therapy, occupational therapy, and speech therapy that would allow Lila to reach her full potential. So the Carpenter family signed up for a waiver to receive Medicaid coverage for what are referred to as home and community based services (HCBS). HCBS provides individuals personalized care in their home or an independent community setting so they don’t have to enter into an institution. Eight years later, Lila is still on the HCBS waiting list.

The Carpenters’ experience is not an anomaly: nearly 820,000 seniors and people with disabilities across the country are on Medicaid HCBS waitlists, with an average wait time of five and a half years. These individuals are left to pay out of pocket for critical care that is generally not covered by private insurance including assistance preparing food, eating, bathing, and getting dressed. Without the HCBS waiver, the Carpenters have had to prioritize Lila’s treatments, cutting down on physical therapy to meet their budget.

This could change with the passage of President Biden’s proposed infrastructure bill. The American Jobs Plan includes $400 billion to expand Medicaid funding for HCBS for people who are currently on waiting lists. The bill would also increase wages and benefits for home care workers paid through Medicaid—predominantly women and people of color who earn an average of $16,200 annually. Despite broad popularity—72 percent of Americans support spending $450 billion to eliminate waitlists for HCBS—Republicans want to remove home and community-based care from the bill.

Republicans who oppose including home and community-based care in the American Jobs Act argue that including home care in the bill stretches the definition of infrastructure. At a May 25 press conference Senator John Barrasso, chair of the Senate Republican Conference, asserted that “Republicans are continuing to focus on things that the American people think of when we talk about infrastructure: roads, bridges, ports, airports, waterways, broadband.” Other parts of the American Jobs Act, by this logic, are not infrastructure. Tennessee Senator Marsha Blackburn clarified this view on Twitter, posting “President Biden’s proposal is about anything but infrastructure” above a graphic citing the $400 billion allocated for home care.

What makes Republicans’ arguments so absurd is that care work is just as central to the functioning of our economy as roads and bridges. Americans understand this: multiple polls indicate that a majority of Americans believe long-term care is part of the country’s infrastructure. As put by Chair of the Council of Economic Advisers Cecilia Rouse, “I can’t go to work, if I don’t have someone who’s taking care of my parents or my children.” And Republicans’ opposition to funding HCBS through the American Jobs Act could backfire; thousands of people responded to Senator Blackburn’s Tweet with negative comments, many of whom noted that alienating seniors is likely not a great political strategy.

If the intention of the infrastructure plan is to get Americans back to work and help the economy rebound from the pandemic, investing in HCBS is a guaranteed win. Research indicates that spending on social care creates twice as many jobs as spending on physical infrastructure. And as the country reopens after the pandemic, many people–especially women–have been slow to re-enter the workforce because of their caregiving responsibilities.
Expanding funding for HCBS is also a key step toward expanding rights for people with disabilities and ending the Medicaid system’s preference for services that are provided in institutional settings. Currently, states receiving Medicaid dollars are required to fund services provided in institutions like nursing homes or assisted living facilities, but not required to fund services that allow people to live with autonomy in their homes and communities. Many individuals in institutional settings do not require a high level of care and would be better served at home due to a lack of programming options–not to mention the disproportionate number of COVID-19 cases and deaths in nursing facilities. Tina Tanner, who lives independently with HCBS support, expressed pride in her ability to live on her own, and frustration that HCBS is not available to others: “it’s something that proved to myself that I can do it and then prove to other people. […] Why can’t these other people that have disabilities do the same thing that she could do?”

Including care work in the infrastructure bill also helps avert future crises. Home care is one of the fastest growing occupations in the country, reflecting both demographic and consumer trends. One in five Americans will be of retirement age by 2030 and the number of individuals who require long-term care services is expected to grow to 27 million by 2050. Older adults increasingly hope to age at home as opposed to entering a nursing home, further driving demand for HCBS. But because home care workers receive poor pay and benefits, the industry is plagued by high turnover rates and a lack of applicants. We should not wait to improve HCBS, just as we wouldn’t wait to replace a bridge until it collapses.

Eliminating Medicaid waitlists and improving pay and benefits for home care workers would dramatically improve the lives of both individuals who need care and their caregivers. Research indicates that better wages and benefits for home care workers would not only improve workers’ financial security and decrease turnover but also increase the quality of care provided. It will allow people with health or functional needs to live with dignity in their communities and ensure those caring for them can do the same. For the Carpenters, “the difference it would make in our lives would be immediate in terms of our ability to care for our child, both the services that she needs and giving her greater access to the community.” If only the Republicans would quit quibbling over semantics.

The Latest

YouTube Thumbnail
The Media Is Ignoring An Economic Boom For Workers
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Wall Street Buying Mobile Home Parks?
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
How Casino Workers Were Left Out Of Clean Air Laws
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Orlando Airport Workers Are Fighting Back Against Overwork And Underpayment
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Inflation Explained: The Real Reason Prices Are Going Up
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Largest Strike in America: Columbia Student Workers Demand a Fair Contract
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
How A Multi-Billion Dollar Bank Merger Could Devastate This Connecticut City
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
3 Ways Biden Can Lower Drug Prices Immediately
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
PetSmart Workers Expose Horrifying Conditions For Workers & Pets
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Cori Bush And Democrats Finalizing A Plan To Lower Insulin Costs
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Kaiser Health Care Workers Are Ready To Strike
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
‘Everything About Walmart Is a Lie’: Walmart Workers Demand $15 Minimum Wage
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Untold History: How America Got (And Lost) Universal Child Care
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Google Threatens Water Supply of Drought-Stricken Town
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
NYC Taxi Drivers Won The Debt Relief They Hungered For
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
HelloFresh Workers Expose Horrific Working Conditions
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
The Fight To Democratize The UAW
Read More
More Perfect Union’s Striketober Coverage
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
The Cheer-Opoly That Needs Government Regulation
Read More
POLL: The Voters Who Democrats Covet Are Cheering On The Strike Wave
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
EXCLUSIVE PHOTOS: Starbucks Spreads Anti-Union Lies In Forced Employee Meetings
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Dollar General Is Illegally Union-Busting
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
The Most Consequential Election You’ve Never Heard Of
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Elizabeth Warren Debunks Republicans’ Lies On Taxes
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
NYC Taxi Drivers Hunger Strike For Debt Relief
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Millionaire Developers Plot To Overturn India Walton’s Election in Buffalo
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Striking Kellogg’s Workers Expose Company’s Lies
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
The Most Pro-Labor President? Here’s What Joe Biden Must Do
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
This Powerful Democrat Is Gutting Biden’s Paid Family Leave Program
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
SCOOP: Dollar General Caught Union Busting
Read More
Strike Tracker: Who In Congress Is Speaking Out For Workers?
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Here’s Why 10,000 John Deere Workers Are on Strike
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Burn The Forest To Save It, Firefighters Argue
Read More
10,000 John Deere Workers Are Officially On Strike
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Ohio’s New Election Maps Are So Rigged Even the GOP Governor Says They’re Illegal
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
CVS Workers Refuse To Settle For Nickels And Dimes
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Working 120 Days Straight: Kellogg’s Workers Go on Strike to Protest Brutal Conditions
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Netflix and Amazon Film Crews Expose Horrific Conditions On Set
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
The Inside Scoop On The Campaign To Primary Kyrsten Sinema
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Amazon Worker Died After Being Assigned To COVID Testing Team
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Voters Rage At Rep. Scott Peters For Selling Out On Drug Prices
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
DeJoy Slows Down USPS Mail Service To Speed Up Privatization
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
60,000 Hollywood Crew Workers Gear Up For First-Ever Strike
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
The Real Reason Grocery Prices Are Skyrocketing
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Starbucks Tries To Crush Historic Union Drive In Buffalo
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Exclusive: Tesla Employee Speaks Out On Rampant Racism At The Company
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
How Spotify Is Killing The Music Industry
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Exclusive: Racist Slurs & Toxic Culture At Tesla
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Meet The Democrat Helping To Destroy The Postal Service
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Apple Is Behind One Of The Largest Thefts In History
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
How Iowa City Defeated Grubhub
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
A Frito-Lay Worker Was Electrocuted, Denied Medical Care & Stalked by Company Agents
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
How Fort Worth Activists Defeated the Dollar Store Invasion
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Forced to Work 12 Hours a Day, 7 Days a Week: The Dark Side of Frito-Lay
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
The NRA You’ve Never Heard Of Is Blocking a $15 Minimum Wage
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
How NYU Grad Students Won A Major Labor Fight On Their Campus
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
These Drivers Could Defeat Uber & Lyft With Their Own App
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
For Fast-Food Workers, the Pandemic Made a Bad Situation Worse. Now They’re Fighting Back.
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
A Modern Day Sweatshop: The Tesla Factory Secrets Elon Musk Doesn’t Want You To Know
Read More
Drivers Protest Uber & Lyft
Gig Workers Take On Big Tech in Massachusetts
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Striking Alabama Coal Miners Put Their Lives on the Line
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Fired By Elon Musk for Unionizing at Tesla
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Sen. Kyrsten Sinema Boosts Republican Assault on Democracy
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
The Real Deal: Mergers Fuel Job Losses
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
Republicans Wage War to Deny More Than 800,000 Disabled and Elderly Americans Home Care
Read More
New Poll: Majority of Voters Support the PRO Act and the For the People Act
Read More
Poll Finds Republicans Support Elizabeth Warren’s Wealth Tax
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
The Dirty Secret Behind Dollar General’s Low Prices
Read More
Majority of Trump Voters & 65% of Americans Support Medicare Expansion
Read More
Workers rally for the PRO Act.
NEW POLL: Bipartisan Support for PRO Act in Arizona, Virginia and Other Key States
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
TV Networks Caught Airing Fake “Interviews” Scripted By Major Corporate Lobby
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
BREAKING: New Details Bolster Likelihood NLRB Will Overturn Amazon Union Election
Read More
Exclusive: Emails Show Amazon Pressured USPS To Install Illegal Dropbox During Union Election
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
NEW REPORT: Amazon’s Most Egregious Illegal Action To Bust The Union Organizing Effort
Read More
YouTube Thumbnail
EXPOSED: The Major Corporations Funding Voter Suppression Efforts in Georgia
Read More